
Having heard that Luca Turin considered Tommy Girl radiant and was giving it five stars in his new book, I wanted to sniff what all the fuss was about. I sprang for a bottle a few weeks ago, and have been smelling it repeatedly ever since.
My reaction to Tommy Girl was/is quite negative (I'll share it below). Given Luca's (and wife Tania's) positive reaction to it though, I wondered if perhaps I was missing something. So I decided to bring in a few experts of my own.
I asked 20 people to sniff Tommy Girl blindly then give me their honest impressions. I also asked them to rate the scent on a five-star scale. I didn't tell them what they were smelling, only that it was a commercial perfume.
These were "normal" men and women (i.e., non-perfumistas), ranging in age from mid-twenties to late-forties. I sprayed the scent on cards and let them sniff and talk while I watched and took notes.
Their reactions were quite varied, but a few things definitely "popped" as researchers like to say. Some surprised me.
For instance, I was amazed to hear that out of 20 people, seven thought Tommy Girl was something their grandmothers would wear! JS called it "antiquish." PS thought it smelled like "old ladies caked with body powder." TA said if he smelled it while nuzzling a girl's neck, "it would throw him off." And MS said it smelled "like you hugged your grandma."
Four people found Tommy Girl to be "too flowery." DF found it to be "very floral and possibly overpowering." JD wrinkled her nose, pushed it away and said it smelled like Estee Lauder Beautiful to her. HS had the impression of a flower garden and "fresh green stems broken open" but said he could only tolerate Tommy Girl outside, during the day.
The three people who thought they smelled fruit in Tommy Girl liked it. The two people who liked the scent best thought Tommy Girl smelled crisp and fresh. SM called it "the perfect summer scent." JS said it was refreshing and felt like "running through a meadow in Springtime." No one smelled any tea notes.
Only five people said they liked it enough to wear or have their significant others wear (three men, two women). And only one person, SM, lit up and said she "absolutely loved it."
Among the men there were quite a few references to other scented products, including candles, air fresheners, laundry detergent, potpourri and bubble bath. NG called it "more Glade than French perfume."
The men who liked it didn't seem terribly excited by it, calling it "above average" and "very nice." EM said it would be "okay if a woman wore it." Only one man obviously enjoyed the scent (he couldn't stop sniffing the card) and said he would "definitely" ask out a woman wearing it (he also said he'd ask out a woman wearing Brut). 
Four men told me they absolutely would not want to smell Tommy Girl on their wives or girlfriends.
It was interesting to see everyone's body language in response to the scented cards. Only two people kept sniffing at them contentedly. The rest put them down after a couple of sniffs, pushed them as far away as possible, or tried to give them back.
And I was a bit surprised that out of 20 people, only one person, NS, recognized it as a Hilfiger scent and finally guessed it was Tommy Girl. She said she used to wear it, but never finished her bottle and now thinks it "smells kinda cheap."
The most colorful reactions came from BR, who generously gave Tommy Girl two stars because "one star would be like poop," and NG, who said that if he were the father of a young daughter, "I'd buy Tommy Girl to keep the boys away from her."
Together these twenty brave reviewers gave Tommy Girl a rating of 2.75 stars.
The first time I smelled Tommy Girl I would've given it a single star. Now that I'm used to it, I'll give it two stars. Not because I like it any more but because I don't hate it as much. Its shock has begun to wear off.
I now expect its screechy, bitter first bite and almost look forward to the cheap-smelling dry down that reminds me of hippie oils at Whole Foods mixed with feminine hygiene products.
Maybe I'm missing something here - some beauty that's right in front of my nose - but I don't believe so. And having heard the reactions of my intrepid reviewers, I know my reaction to Tommy Girl isn't all that strange.
What's your take on it? I hope you'll take the time to check out what other perfumistas are saying about Tommy Girl at Helg's Perfume Shrine and Perfume Posse.